False Assault Allegation Against Supervisor Was Just Cause For Dismissal: Video Evidence Was Conclusive
24, July 24, 2016 - Filed in: Arbitration Cases
An employee who filed a written complaint, falsely alleging that his supervisor deliberately ran into him with a sharp blow from his shoulder, was dismissed for cause, an arbitrator has held.
Unfortunately for the employee, video evidence showed his allegation to be false.
The employee, a warehouse worker, had seven years of service and had received two prior suspensions in the previous twelve-month period.
The supervisor denied the allegation, and no witnesses supported the employee's version of events. Video evidence showed the corridor at the time when, according to the employee, he was assaulted. The video showed that no such assault took place.
The arbitrator held that the evidence was overwhelmingly against the employee's account of what had occurred. In particular, the video showed that there was no contact. The employee had falsified the allegation against his supervisor. This was very serious, as the allegation was that the supervisor had committed assault. That allegation, if accepted, "could have extremely negative consequences" for the supervisor including possible criminal charges. The allegation was calculated to harm the supervisor. The making of the allegation was so serious as to "undermine the possibility of any ongoing employment relationship".
As such, the employee was dismissed for just cause.
Note: This a reprint of an article by Adrian Miedema of Dentons.